Skip to content
MLB

Yankees-Padres SGP: Ray Ks, Tatis and Judge Total Bases at Petco Park

A three-leg same game parlay for Yankees at Padres Saturday night: Robbie Ray strikeouts, Fernando Tatis Jr. total bases, and Aaron Judge total bases at Petco Park.

By Bill Christy Updated September 5, 2026
Fernando Tatis Jr. batting for the San Diego Padres at Petco Park

Saturday night at Petco Park is must-watch TV, and FOX knows it — the Yankees roll into San Diego for a nationally televised showdown that has playoff atmosphere written all over it, even though the calendar still says September. First pitch is 7:15 PM ET, and the pitching matchup alone is worth the price of admission: Carlos Rodón (4-3, 3.20 ERA) taking the ball for New York against Robbie Ray (11-7, 3.14 ERA) for San Diego. Two lefties who can miss bats, two lineups loaded with thunder, and a ballpark that can play either way depending on the night’s marine layer. This is exactly the kind of game that was built for a same game parlay.

We’ve built a three-leg SGP around the pitching duel and the two biggest bats in the building, and books have this total sitting right around 7.5 to 8 runs — tight enough that every leg here has real juice behind it.

Leg 1: Robbie Ray Over 6.5 Strikeouts

Ray has been the Padres’ best story of the second half, sitting at 11-7 with a 3.14 ERA and swing-and-miss stuff that plays up against a Yankees lineup still prone to chase. He’s coming off a start against Tampa Bay where he worked six innings and struck out four, but Ray has been more dominant than that line suggests — his strikeout rate has been trending toward elite territory all summer, and Petco’s spacious gaps reward a pitcher who can just get outs on strikes instead of relying on the defense behind him.

New York’s lineup has swing-and-miss guys stacked from top to bottom, and a well-rested Ray at home, on national TV, with a chance to outduel a former Cy Young winner, is a recipe for a big strikeout total. Give him 6-plus punchouts here.

Leg 2: Fernando Tatis Jr. Over 1.5 Total Bases

Tatis is having another prototypical Tatis season — .284 average, 19 home runs, 70 RBIs and 31 stolen bases, the kind of five-tool production that makes him a matchup nightmare regardless of who’s on the mound. But here’s the wrinkle that makes this leg spicy: Tatis has been historically hitless against Rodón in their head-to-head history. That’s the kind of stat that usually scares bettors off a prop like this — except it cuts the other way for a total-bases play, because a hitter this talented going cold against one specific pitcher over a small sample is exactly the kind of “due” spot that sharp bettors love to attack.

Add in the fact that Petco Park is his home ballpark, where he’s comfortable in the box and has feasted for years, and Tatis reaching base with extra pop — even a double instead of a single — clears this number more often than not. This is the total-bases market, not batting average, so a walk-adjacent night doesn’t kill the leg either; he just needs one well-struck ball to get to two bases.

Leg 3: Aaron Judge Over 0.5 Total Bases

Judge has dealt with a slower overall batting line this year, sitting at .248 with 17 home runs and 38 RBIs, a number that reflects missed time more than declining bat speed. When healthy and in the box, Judge remains one of the most dangerous hitters alive — his exit velocities and barrel rates haven’t budged, and a .908 OPS says the underlying performance is still elite even if the surface stats look modest by his own absurd standards.

Facing Ray, a pitcher who lives in the zone and isn’t afraid to challenge big hitters, Judge just needs a single, a double, a walk that turns into extra bases on a wild pitch, or obviously a home run to clear a total-bases floor this low. In a game FOX is broadcasting nationally specifically because of moments like this, expect Judge to be aggressive early in counts and make Ray pay for any mistake left over the plate.

The Full Parlay

Stack it together: Robbie Ray going over 6.5 strikeouts, Fernando Tatis Jr. clearing 1.5 total bases at home, and Aaron Judge getting on the board with at least a half a total base of his own. It’s a parlay built on two future Hall of Fame-caliber hitters doing what they do best and a red-hot lefty carving up a lineup that will chase his slider all night. With the total sitting around 7.5-8 and both bullpens shaky late, this is a game that should have offense stacked in bunches — exactly the environment where a same game parlay like this cashes. Check your FanDuel promo code before first pitch and load this one up for a Saturday night under the lights at Petco.

Free · Weekly

The smartest 5 minutes in betting

Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.