The MLB player prop board is stacked today, and instead of leaning into one category, we’re going full buffet — the three best bets on the entire slate, regardless of whether they come from a bat or an arm. Two Blue Jays and a Dodgers superstar make up this trio, and all three are backed by real, recent numbers that make the price look soft.
Grab your book, check the live lines before first pitch, and let’s get into why these three props deserve a spot on your card tonight.
Shohei Ohtani Keeps Doing Shohei Ohtani Things
Shohei Ohtani has been an absolute machine against right-handed pitching, and tonight he draws a righty in Sean Manaea when the Dodgers take on the Mets. Ohtani is running a .987 OPS against right-handers this season with a .541 slugging percentage, numbers that put him firmly in the “must-fade the under” tier of hitters on any given night.
The total bases prop sitting at Over 1.5 is the play here. Ohtani doesn’t need a home run to clear this number — a double, or a single plus a stolen base situation, gets it done just as easily. Given his track record of stringing together multi-hit, extra-base-hit games against right-handed starters, betting the over on a number this modest feels like taking free value.
Manaea has been solid enough for the Mets, but he’s exactly the type of pitch-to-contact lefty-neutral arm that Ohtani has feasted on time and again this season. Betting against Ohtani’s total bases prop against a righty starter has been a losing proposition more nights than not, and there’s no reason to expect tonight looks any different.
Vladdy Jr. Is Automatic Against Boston
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has turned into one of the most reliable bats in baseball, and the matchup against Boston only sweetens the pot. Guerrero is a strong contact hitter who rarely goes an entire game without putting the bat on the ball, and the -330 price to record a hit reflects just how often he gets it done.
Guerrero’s swing decisions have been elite all year — he chases far less than most middle-of-the-order bats and consistently squares up quality pitching. Against a Red Sox staff that hasn’t been able to consistently miss bats, Guerrero projects as one of the safer “to record a hit” plays on the board tonight.
Yes, -330 isn’t a number that’s going to make anyone rich on its own, but that’s exactly the point of a play like this — it’s the kind of foundational leg you build a same game parlay around, not the one you’re taking to Vegas by itself. Pair it with something at plus money and you’ve got a real ticket.
Yesavage’s Strikeout Stuff Travels
Trey Yesavage has quickly become one of the more electric arms in Toronto’s rotation, and his strikeout numbers back it up — he’s averaging north of five strikeouts per start this season, comfortably clearing the Over 5.5 Ks number he’s set at tonight against Boston.
The Red Sox lineup has had its swing-and-miss issues against power arms with a good breaking ball, and Yesavage’s stuff plays exactly into that. At -113, the price is nearly a coin flip in terms of payout, but his season-long strikeout rate says the over should hit far more often than not against this lineup.
Rookie or not, Yesavage has shown he can miss bats deep into games, and as long as he’s not on a strict pitch count tonight, five-plus strikeouts should be well within reach before he ever sees the bullpen phone ring.
Lock These In
Three different bet types, three different games in feel, and three plays that all hold up under the numbers. This is the kind of mixed board that rewards spreading your action around instead of stacking everything into one category — check the current lines at your preferred sportsbook before locking anything in, since prices can move closer to first pitch.
- Shohei Ohtani OVER 1.5 Total Bases
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr. To Record a Hit (-330)
- Trey Yesavage OVER 5.5 Strikeouts (-113)
If you’re looking to combine a couple of these into one ticket, our same game parlay guide breaks down how to build a smarter combo bet around plays exactly like these.
The smartest 5 minutes in betting
Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.