Skip to content
MLB

MLB Best Bets for May 13, 2026: Ohtani Strikeouts, Gavin Sheets Total Bases, and Curtis Mead Home Run

Wednesday’s MLB best bets feature Shohei Ohtani strikeouts, Gavin Sheets total bases at a favorable park, and Curtis Mead home run in the number one HR park in baseball.

By Adam Hutchinson Updated May 13, 2026
Shohei Ohtani pitching for the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium

Wednesday’s MLB slate has something for everyone — a Cy Young-caliber ace going deep into a marquee matchup, a park-factor play with clear plus-money value, and a longshot home run bet backed by elite spray charts and the best HR park in baseball. Here are three plays that represent the best of the board on May 13.

Shohei Ohtani STRIKEOUTS OVER 6.5 (-114) — LAD vs SF, 10:10 PM

Shohei Ohtani is pitching at a level that defies conventional description right now. Through eight starts in 2026, the Los Angeles Dodgers ace has posted a 2-2 record with a 0.97 ERA, 42 strikeouts in 37 innings, and an absurd 0.81 WHIP. His ERA essentially rounds to 1.00, which in May means he is operating at an entirely different level from the rest of the field. He is averaging 7 strikeouts per game, and the 6.5 line is asking for slightly below his average.

Tonight’s matchup is against the San Francisco Giants, a divisional rival that Ohtani has faced before and dominated. The late start — 10:10 PM — sets up as appointment viewing for west coast fans and late-night bettors looking for value on a pitcher who is quietly running one of the best stretches of any starter in recent memory. At -114, this is about as clean a strikeout prop as the market offers on a slate where most of the better numbers have been bet down. Browse the MLB odds and you will see that Ohtani’s line is actually among the more reasonable ones available tonight.

Gavin Sheets TOTAL BASES OVER 1.5 (+220) — SD @ MIL, 7:40 PM

Gavin Sheets is one of the more interesting plus-money batter plays of the week. The San Diego Padres outfielder bats left-handed and is slotted fourth in the lineup tonight at American Family Field — a park that ranks fourth in MLB for left-handed home run production. The roof at American Family Field will be closed, which adds an estimated five degrees of heat and creates conditions where the ball carries further than in open air.

The projection models show positive expected value on Sheets at these odds, and the park-lineup combination is exactly the kind of factor edge that generates plus-money wins in a small sample. Two total bases is a threshold that can be cleared via a single and a double, two singles with a stolen base, or a home run. At +220, you are getting paid generously to bet on a left-handed hitter with power potential in one of the more favorable left-handed parks in the league. This is the type of value play that builds bankrolls over a long season when you find it consistently.

Curtis Mead HR OVER 0.5 (+253) — WSH @ CIN, 6:40 PM

Curtis Mead checks in as the highest-value bet on this slate at +253, and the analytical case for it is stronger than the price suggests. The Washington Nationals third baseman bats right-handed and is playing tonight at Great American Ball Park, which ranks as the number one park in all of MLB for right-handed batter home runs. The wind is blowing out toward center field at 16.3 mph. Those two conditions alone would make Mead worth looking at.

Mead ranks in the 83rd percentile for opposite-field flyball rate, meaning he sprays the ball to all parts of the field with lift and regularly generates warning-track contact that can clear the wall with the right conditions. Tonight, the park and wind create exactly those conditions. He is batting second in the lineup, facing Nick Lodolo, a left-handed pitcher who has made only one appearance this season. Mead at +253 is asking you to believe in roughly a one-in-three chance of a home run, and his underlying data in this park-wind combination suggests the true probability is higher than that.

How to Play These Picks Tonight

These three plays work on their own merits, but they also build well together. Ohtani is the safest of the three and anchors any parlay nicely. Sheets at +220 adds juice to a multi-leg ticket without reaching for a longshot. Mead at +253 is a true value play that either hits big or serves as a compelling single-game bet on its own.

If you are shopping these props across platforms, an Underdog promo code or the PrizePicks promo code can extend your bankroll before the first pitch tonight. Line shop early — the Ohtani prop in particular tends to move before the late game, and locking in -114 now is better than paying more juice at gametime. As always, verify starting lineups before placing any wager and bet within your limits.

Free · Weekly

The smartest 5 minutes in betting

Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.