Game 2 of the American League Championship Series sets all eyes on Toronto Blue Jays rookie right-hander Trey Yesavage to even the series against the Seattle Mariners. Yesterday we watched Bryce Miller dominate this Jay’s lineup to a full 6 innings of 1 run ball, and it doesn’t get any easier in game 2.
I have two props that stand out for tonight as Yesavage and the Jays have a chance to head back to Seattle tied 1-1.
Strikeouts Coming?
Yesavage made his postseason debut against the Yankees and turned heads, including mine. Easily one of the most dominant outings of the playoffs so far, as all of the rookies have had impressive games in the 2025 playoffs, including Schlittler, Early, Misiorowski, and Sasaki.
The rookie struck out eleven batters over five and one-third no-hit innings while allowing just 1 free pass. Yesavage offers fantastic command with a 95 mph 4-seam fastball he utilizes 45% of the time, while keeping hitters honest, guessing between a slider and splitter he balances using around 28% and 26% respectively.
Yesavage’s fastball rides through the zone and could keep this Mariners offense guessing. Seattle’s lineup has plenty of power but could get caught chasing pitches out of the zone.
Seattle’s projected lineup offers six hitters that strike out 20%, five hitters at 22% and four hitters above 25% to RHP in 2025. Over the season, the Mariners struck out the 10th highest to RHP at 23% and 8th highest at 26% over the last 30 days.
Can Seattle’s Bats Find the Rookie?
Considering how efficient Yesavage looked against the Yankees in a huge spot, I like to back him here again. No manager wants to go to the bullpen unless needed, and Yesavage is young enough to allow some leash if he’s pitching well.
Yesavage faces a lineup that offers four hitters hitting under .167 in the playoffs, six under .217. The biggest test is certainly Cal Raleigh, who is hitting .400 in the postseason, but his season average vs RHP does drop to .231. If Yesavage can keep Raleigh and company inside the park, this should be a tight game. The roof is projected to be closed, and I expect runs to be at a premium once again.
At plus odds, I like both as my premium members are locked in both plus money plays. If these move to minus money and you are a bettor who doesn’t want two plays on the same player, I lean toward the strikeouts over the outs. If you also want another look, I love Yesavage 5 strikeouts paired with Blake Snell to find 6 strikeouts, which is -110 on Hardrock.
Best Bets
Trey Yesavage (TOR) OVER 5.5 Strikeouts (+105, Novig)
Trey Yesavage (TOR) OVER 13.5 Outs (+106, Novig)
The smartest 5 minutes in betting
Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.