Skip to content
MLB

3 MLB Props Worth Betting on Monday May 4, 2026: Witt, Rice, and a Sneaky Under

Monday’s MLB slate has 12 games and three props that stand out — a hits bet, a breakout total bases play, and a sneaky under on a pitcher whose ERA is hiding a low strikeout rate.

By Mike Noblin Updated May 4, 2026
Nick Martinez

It is Monday, baseball is back after a rest day for most teams, and there are 12 games on the board tonight. That means 12 chances to find value, and after going through the full slate, three plays jumped off the page as the kind of bets you actually feel good about — the type you tell your buddy about over the first inning.

These are not overthought parlay legs or obscure micro-props. These are real plays with real reasons behind them, from the kind of 12-game slate that rewards anyone who does a little homework before the games tip off.

Bobby Witt Jr. Has a Problem With Logan Gilbert, and Logan Gilbert Has a Problem in 2026

Bobby Witt Jr. is one of the best young shortstops in baseball and one of the most fun players to watch in the AL. On Monday night, the Kansas City Royals travel to Seattle to face Logan Gilbert, who enters the game at 1-3 with a 4.03 ERA — a significantly worse mark than what Gilbert posted in 2024 and 2025 when he was one of the more reliable starters in the league.

Here is the thing: Witt has a brutal historical matchup against Gilbert, which makes the standard hits prop an interesting target from the under direction. His career average against Gilbert is among the worst of any top-ten hitter in the league against any single pitcher. However, the real play here is simpler — Witt is one of the best overall hitters in the Royals lineup, he is on a good team that creates run-scoring situations, and the Over 0.5 hits is available at near even money on most major books. Witt is hitting around .280 on the season and has at least one hit in more than 70 percent of his games in 2026. That is the straightforward version of the play: take a great hitter to get a hit, at a fair price, on a game night.

If you want to add a twist, his Hits+Runs+RBIs Over 1.5 has positive expected value based on public projection data. Witt creates enough action — steals, walks turned into runs, RBI opportunities as one of Kansas City’s best run-producers — that crossing 1.5 combined contributions is genuinely likely given his current form and his team’s offensive output. Check the MLB betting guide if you are newer to this type of prop and want a breakdown of how combination props work.

Ben Rice Is the Breakout Story No One Outside of New York Is Talking About

Ben Rice is having a legitimate breakout year for the New York Yankees. Through the first 34 games of the season, Rice is batting .330 with a .717 slugging percentage and 11 home runs. His OPS versus left-handed pitching — which is what he will get from some portion of the Baltimore pitching staff tonight — is 1.324. That is a number that belongs to a player who is locked in, seeing the ball well, and doing damage.

Tonight at Yankee Stadium, Rice faces the Orioles, who send Shane Baz to the mound. Baz has a 4.50 ERA and has struggled to keep the ball in the park against premium contact from right-handed hitters. Rice, a left-handed bat, will get favorable looks against Baltimore’s bullpen arms later in the game. His total bases Over 1.5 has hit at a high rate recently, and with a home run prop that is available at plus money on many books, this is one of those plays where you feel like the book has not fully updated for who Rice is right now versus who he was last year. He is no longer a platoon piece — he is one of the more dangerous bats in the Yankees lineup.

If you want to parlay anything tonight, Rice’s total bases as a leg alongside something else on the slate is worth considering. The Yankees lineup is one of the best in baseball, they are 23-11 on the season, and Rice is a central reason why. Check your FanDuel promo code if you are looking for a new book with good prop coverage.

Nick Martinez Has Been Nasty in Tampa Bay — But the Toronto Lineup Can Hit

Nick Martinez has been one of the surprise stories of 2026. The Tampa Bay Rays right-hander enters Monday at 2-1 with a 1.70 ERA and 24 strikeouts through the season. Those are legitimate numbers from a pitcher who came into 2026 without much fanfare. However, the prop play here actually targets the under on his strikeout total against the Toronto Blue Jays, who are a better offensive club than their 16-18 record suggests.

Martinez averages only 2.9 strikeouts per start in 2026, meaning his K/9 translates to a low per-game total even with good ERA results. His 1.70 ERA is powered by a strong ground ball rate and excellent defense behind him — not swing-and-miss stuff. The Blue Jays have a lineup that makes contact and puts balls in play, which plays against high strikeout totals for any pitcher. A strikeout line of 4.5 for Martinez, if the books post it in that range, would represent real value on the under given his 24 strikeouts across the season.

This is the kind of prop that is easy to miss because you look at his ERA and think he is dominant. He is effective — but he is not a strikeout pitcher, and the Blue Jays are not a strikeout-prone lineup. The game is at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg at 6:40 PM ET. If you want to find this prop before first pitch, the MLB odds page is a quick way to compare lines across books.

The Monday Night Card — Three Plays Worth Your Attention

A great Monday night lineup with three distinct plays: a hits prop on one of the AL’s best young shortstops, a breakout total bases play on the Yankees’ most exciting bat, and an under on a pitcher whose gaudy ERA is disguising a very average strikeout rate. All three have real reasons behind them and represent plays you can feel confident about heading into the game.

  • Bobby Witt Jr. OVER 0.5 Hits vs Seattle Mariners (9:40 PM ET) — check your book for current lines
  • Ben Rice OVER 1.5 Total Bases vs Baltimore Orioles (7:05 PM ET) — check your book for current lines
  • Nick Martinez UNDER 4.5 Strikeouts vs Toronto Blue Jays (6:40 PM ET) — check your book for current lines

Line shop before you place anything — these plays are good at fair prices, but paying bad juice erases the edge. Enjoy the slate tonight.

Free · Weekly

The smartest 5 minutes in betting

Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.