3 MLB Props to Back for Padres-Brewers NLDS Game 2: Henderson, Turang, and Bauers Deliver

The Brewers are up 1-0 on the Padres after a nail-biting 3-2 win in Game 1 of the NLDS, and Milwaukee gets to put the hammer down on Sunday with American Family Field rocking for Game 2. With Jacob Misiorowski already putting on a show in the opener, the Brewers are rolling into this one with their postseason rookie, Logan Henderson, on the mound and a lineup that has been doing damage all October. We dug through the board and found three props that line up perfectly with how this Brewers team is built right now — a pitcher dealing with swagger, and two bats that have been money all year.

None of these are coin flips. Each one is backed by real trends from the 2026 season, and together they make for one of the more entertaining tickets you’ll find on the Padres-Brewers slate.

Logan Henderson Keeps the Streak Alive (Under 3.5 Hits Allowed, +101)

Logan Henderson has quietly put together one of the most remarkable rookie seasons in recent postseason memory. Across 23 career starts dating back to last year, he has never allowed more than three earned runs in a single outing — a streak that ties Zac Gallen for the longest to begin a career since the mound was moved back in 1893. That kind of consistency doesn’t happen by accident, and it’s showing up in the box score: Henderson finished the regular season 11-3 with a 2.47 ERA, a tidy 0.84 WHIP, and 110 strikeouts over 98.1 innings.

What makes the under on hits allowed so appealing here is Henderson’s ability to miss barrels and limit hard contact even when he’s not racking up strikeouts. He’s the kind of pitcher who can scatter soft contact across five or six innings without letting a game snowball, and San Diego’s lineup — minus Jake Cronenworth’s typical punch and without Ryan Sheets in the lineup for Game 1 — hasn’t been overwhelming against pitching with this level of command. At +101, this is essentially a coin-flip price on a guy who has made a career out of avoiding exactly this kind of damage.

Brice Turang Keeps Driving in Runs (Over 0.5 RBI, +190)

Brice Turang has been one of the most productive hitters in baseball that casual fans still sleep on. He closed the regular season with 93-plus RBI, a .266 average, and nearly 20 home runs from the two-hole — numbers that would headline most lineups, let alone one that also features Jackson Chourio and Jake Bauers. Turang’s blend of contact skills and opportunistic baserunning has made him a plus-RBI bat all year, and the Brewers have been getting runners on base in bunches during this series.

At +190 for just one RBI, the math favors the bettor. Turang doesn’t need a home run or extra-base hit to cash this — a sacrifice fly, a two-out single with a man on third, or a productive groundout in the right situation all get the job done. If you’re shopping for the best number on this one, it pays to compare a few sportsbook promo codes before locking in your bet, since odds on RBI props can shift fast closer to first pitch. With American Family Field packed and the Brewers’ offense clicking after a Game 1 win, expect Milwaukee to keep pressuring Michael King and a Padres bullpen that’s already been taxed once this series.

Jake Bauers Crosses the Plate (Over 0.5 Run, +130)

Jake Bauers has quietly been one of the most efficient power bats in Milwaukee’s lineup all season, finishing with 26 home runs and an OPS pushing toward .900 territory. More importantly for this prop, Bauers gets on base at an elite clip — his .384 on-base percentage during his peak stretch shows a hitter who draws walks, works counts, and finds ways to be a baserunner even in games where the hits aren’t falling. He’s also been running a strong better-than-coinflip rate of 49.5% to record at least one hit in this matchup, which only adds to the case that he’s going to see the bases in a meaningful way on Sunday.

With Milwaukee hitting in front of and around some of the best bat-to-ball hitters in the league, Bauers doesn’t need to do the heavy lifting himself — he just needs to get on and let Turang, Chourio, or whoever’s up next drive him in. At +130, betting on a middle-of-the-order bat with this kind of OBP to score a single run in a game the Brewers are favored to control is good value.

Lock These In

This card leans into exactly what Milwaukee has shown all October: shutdown pitching from unexpected sources and a deep, opportunistic lineup that finds ways to put runs on the board. If the Brewers protect home field the way they did in Game 1, all three of these should hit without much sweat.

• Logan Henderson Under 3.5 Hits Allowed (+101)
• Brice Turang Over 0.5 RBI (+190)
• Jake Bauers Over 0.5 Run (+130)

Stack all three together and you’re looking at a juicy combined price on a Brewers team that’s playing with total control of this series. If you want to shop lines across multiple apps, our MLB odds page is a good place to start. Check your book for the latest numbers before locking anything in, but the value here is real.