3 Best MLB Props to Back for Yankees-Rays ALDS Game 2 on October 5

Game 2 of the ALDS between the Yankees and Rays is shaping up to be a slugfest in disguise, and the prop market already knows it. Tampa Bay stole Game 1 at Tropicana Field and now sends Freddy Peralta to the mound against Cam Schlittler in a matchup loaded with swing-and-miss stuff and thump in the lineup. First pitch is 8:00 PM ET on Monday, October 5, with the Rays holding a 1-0 series lead and the crowd buzzing for a chance to put New York on the brink.

Instead of overthinking this one, we went straight to the board and picked the three juiciest numbers regardless of category — a power swing, a strikeout artist, and a sneaky-productive bat near the bottom of the Rays order. These are the props that jumped off the page.

Junior Caminero to Go Deep Off Schlittler (+400)

Junior Caminero has been must-watch television all season, and his career numbers against Cam Schlittler make this one of the spicier plays on the board. The 23-year-old third baseman finished the regular season with 42 home runs, 101 RBI, and a .276 average, ranking him sixth in MLB in slugging percentage among qualified hitters. That kind of bat-to-ball power paired with thunder isn’t common, and it’s exactly why oddsmakers keep respecting him even in a tough righty-on-righty spot.

Dig into the history and it gets more interesting: Caminero has gone deep off Schlittler before in a small sample that produced a lofty .786 OPS. Schlittler has been nearly untouchable this October — 10 strikeouts and just two hits allowed over 6.1 innings in his Division Series debut — but even dominant stuff gets hit when a hitter has seen it well previously. At plus-400, you’re getting paid nearly 4-to-1 for a hitter with 42 home runs this year and a track record against this exact arm.

Tropicana Field’s dome does suppress some power, but Caminero has shown he doesn’t need a jet stream to do damage. This is the long-shot play of the slate that still has real statistical backing.

Cam Schlittler Over 6.5 Strikeouts (-146)

If you want something closer to a lock, look no further than the Yankees’ ace. Schlittler was a revelation in 2026, going 14-6 with a 1.95 ERA and racking up 239 strikeouts across his starts — a strikeout-per-game average north of 7.2. He’s not just a volume guy either; his 0.92 WHIP tells you he’s missing bats while barely putting anyone on base, a brutal combination for opposing lineups.

His Game 1 ALDS relief/spot appearance only reinforced the trend — 10 strikeouts in 6.1 innings against a Rays lineup that will see him again tonight. Tampa Bay’s offense can put the ball in play and has shown flashes of power, but this is a unit that has also chased Schlittler’s secondary stuff before. At -146, the number is baked in realistically given his full-season rate, and legitimate K-prop markets elsewhere on this very slate have it priced even shorter. With the Rays needing to be aggressive and Schlittler attacking the zone in a swingy ballpark, 7+ strikeouts feels like the floor, not the ceiling.

Jonathan Aranda Mixed Bag: RBI and Pop-Up Power (+260 / +630)

Jonathan Aranda doesn’t get the headlines that Caminero does, but the Rays first baseman quietly put together a .274 average with 22 home runs and 92 RBI during the regular season — an OPS near .790 that makes him one of the more underrated bats in this lineup. He’s been a run-producer all year, consistently finding ways to drive in teammates even when he’s not the one going deep.

The Over 0.5 RBI prop at +260 lines up well with that profile — Aranda has shown an ability to deliver with runners on, and in a lineup spot that regularly sees traffic ahead of him against a Yankees staff still working through its ALDS rotation plans, the RBI chances should be there early and often. Pair that with the Over 0.5 home run prop at +630 as a true value dart — FanDuel’s own research has Aranda among the day’s top home run picks across all of baseball, a notable nod given how deep this slate is during the Division Series round. Tropicana Field tempers some fly balls, but Aranda has enough bat speed to turn one around regardless of park factors.

Shop these same markets at your preferred book and check the latest MLB odds before locking in, since lines on secondary props like these can move throughout the day as lineups are finalized.

Today’s Edge

Game 2 has everything — a dominant starter chasing strikeouts, a power bat with real history against him, and an underrated run producer who keeps finding ways onto the stat sheet. Here’s the full board:

• Junior Caminero OVER 0.5 Home Runs (+400)
• Cam Schlittler OVER 6.5 Strikeouts (-146)
• Jonathan Aranda OVER 0.5 RBI (+260) / OVER 0.5 Home Runs (+630)

If you’re building a same game parlay around tonight’s ALDS Game 2, this trio gives you a legitimate mix of a safer anchor and two live longshots with real numbers behind them — exactly the kind of balance a good same game parlay needs.