The Milwaukee Brewers open a four-game set against the Pittsburgh Pirates on Monday night at American Family Field, and this one has all the makings of a fun same game parlay. First pitch is 7:40 p.m. ET, with Brandon Sproat toeing the rubber for the Brewers against Pirates rookie Bubba Chandler, and neither pitcher has exactly been lights-out lately. That combination — two shaky arms, a Milwaukee lineup that’s raking, and a total that opened at 8.5 — is the kind of setup that gets bettors excited.
Milwaukee is favored at home at -144 on the moneyline, with the total sitting at 8.5 and the over currently priced around +104. Add in a couple of live home run props from Milwaukee’s lineup, and you’ve got a same game parlay with real juice behind it. Here’s how we’re building it out.
Leg 1: Brewers Moneyline (-144)
Milwaukee comes into this series at 69-42, running away with the NL Central, while Pittsburgh sits at 56-57 and well back in the division race. The Brewers have the better bullpen, the better lineup, and they’re at home. Brandon Sproat has struggled to a 5.05 ERA and a 3-6 record this season, but Bubba Chandler hasn’t been much better for Pittsburgh, sitting at 4.56 with a 3-8 mark and a bloated 1.41 WHIP. When both starters are shaky, the deeper, more talented roster tends to win out, and that’s Milwaukee in this spot.
The Brewers also have real recent momentum in the batter’s box. William Contreras has racked up 17 doubles, a triple, 10 home runs, and 57 RBI on the year, and Brice Turang has been on an absolute tear, going 15-for-38 with a double and two homers over his last 10 games. That kind of offensive form against a rookie righty in Chandler makes Milwaukee the safer side to lean on here.
Leg 2: Total Over 8.5 Runs
This is the number our model likes most today, projecting the over at close to +104 value. Both bullpens have had their issues, and neither Sproat nor Chandler has been able to consistently pitch deep into games this season — Chandler is averaging right around five innings a start, and Sproat is even shorter at roughly 4.2 innings per outing. That means both bullpens are getting used earlier than teams would like, and Milwaukee’s pitching staff overall ranks just middle-of-the-pack in ERA at 3.48 compared to Pittsburgh’s 4.26.
Add in a Brewers offense that’s first in the majors in hits per game and a Pirates lineup that’s also hitting a respectable .259 as a team, and this profiles as a track meet more than a pitcher’s duel. The total has crept a touch since opening, but 8.5 still looks beatable when neither starter can be trusted to work efficiently into the sixth inning.
Leg 3: Brice Turang to Hit a Home Run (+600)
Turang is priced at +600 to go deep on FanDuel, and given how he’s swinging it right now, that number stands out. He’s hitting .271 with 16 home runs on the season, but it’s his recent surge — two homers and a double in his last 10 games while going 15-for-38 — that makes this the value play of the parlay. Chandler has already allowed 10 home runs this season in just over 100 innings, so the long ball is very much in play against him, and Turang has the hot bat to cash this leg.
Leg 4: Jackson Chourio Over 1.5 Total Bases
Chourio has been one of Milwaukee’s most dangerous hitters all year, batting .276 with 13 home runs and an .460 slugging percentage across 77 games, and he’s priced at +450 to homer outright on Monday. Rather than banking on the longball alone, we like him to clear 1.5 total bases — a number he can reach with any extra-base hit or a multi-hit game. Facing a Pirates rookie starter who’s allowed 10 home runs and owns a 1.41 WHIP, Chourio should see pitches to drive throughout this one.
The Full Parlay
Stack these four legs — Brewers moneyline, the over 8.5, Turang going deep, and Chourio clearing 1.5 total bases — and you’ve got a same game parlay that leans into Milwaukee’s offensive strength while banking on shaky pitching from both sides pushing this one over the total. For bettors looking to build their own version, check the same game parlays guide for more strategy on stacking legs like this, and always confirm live odds at your book of choice before locking anything in, since props like these can move fast once lineups are confirmed.
This is an aggressive, entertainment-forward parlay that leans on volume and boom-or-bust homer props, so treat it as a fun long-shot ticket rather than a conservative single-game play — but with Milwaukee’s bats running hot and neither starter inspiring much confidence, all four legs have a real path to hitting.
The smartest 5 minutes in betting
Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.