Eleven games on a Thursday means opportunities everywhere, but not everything on the board is worth your money. These three props stand out because the numbers back them up, the matchups line up, and the recent form makes them hard to ignore. This is the best of the board for May 14.
These are fun plays with real substance behind them. Let’s get into it.
Kyle Harrison Is Quietly Becoming a Problem
The Milwaukee Brewers have an absolute gem in Kyle Harrison. The 24-year-old left-hander has posted a 2.41 ERA through seven starts in 2026, with 41 strikeouts in 33.2 innings. That works out to an 11.0 K/9 rate, which is elite. His slurve has been virtually unhittable, generating a 29-plus percent whiff rate on swings, and batters are slashing just .231 against him this season.
Today Harrison draws the San Diego Padres at American Family Field. San Diego is a dangerous lineup on paper, but Harrison’s most recent start was an absolute masterpiece: 12 strikeouts over six shutout innings against Pittsburgh on April 26. The game before that, he put up eight Ks in his first start of the season. His floor has been six strikeouts in every outing, and the home park in Milwaukee does not suppress strikeout totals the way some pitcher-friendly venues do. The Brewers also play up-tempo defense, which keeps Harrison in games longer.
His strikeout line is typically set in the 6.5 to 7.5 range. Given that he is coming off a 12-strikeout game and has the stuff to replicate it, the over is a strong play. Check current lines at your sportsbook.
Matt Olson Is Having a Monster Season and the Cubs Are Tonight’s Victims
Matt Olson is one of the best first basemen in baseball right now and his 2026 numbers prove it. He is hitting .294 with 14 home runs, 37 RBIs, and a .644 slugging percentage through 41 games. That slugging number is not a misprint. Over his last 30 games he has been even more dominant, generating a total bases pace that puts him among the NL leaders. His game log shows multi-base games in the majority of recent outings, including a home run in the ninth inning just two days ago against the Cubs themselves.
Tonight’s matchup is against Ben Brown of the Cubs, a right-handed pitcher with a 1.82 ERA through four starts, but only 27 strikeouts in 34-plus innings. Brown succeeds through contact management rather than dominance, which means Olson, who squares the ball up relentlessly, projects to make hard contact. Olson’s total bases line is typically set at 1.5, and given his season average of well over 1.5 total bases per game and his prior familiarity with Brown’s stuff, this is one of the cleanest spots on the board.
Career numbers against the Cubs sit at .262 with six home runs in 28 games, but 2026 Olson is operating at a different level. Back the total bases over.
Bryce Harper in May Is Absolutely Unreal
Bryce Harper has decided that May is his month. After a quiet March (.100 average) and a solid April (.298), Harper has erupted in the current calendar month to the tune of .344/.447/.813 with four home runs in 10 games. His slugging percentage in May alone is .813. He is one of the hottest bats in baseball right now, and tonight he takes that form to Fenway Park to face the Boston Red Sox.
On the mound for Boston is Ranger Suarez, a left-handed pitcher returning from a minor hamstring issue. Harper, who bats left-handed, generally thrives when fully locked in because his swing generates tremendous bat speed and his pitch recognition is elite. His hits line is typically set at 1.5. In May alone, he is averaging more than one hit per game at better than .340, meaning the simple over 0.5 hits line or the over 1.5 hits line both carry appeal depending on what your book is offering.
The hottest batter in the sport, going to a friendly road park, against a pitcher returning from injury who historically performs better later in the season when fully healthy. Harper at or around 1.5 hits is the most exciting play on tonight’s board.
Thursday’s Best of the Board
Three different kinds of plays, all pointing the same direction. Harrison’s strikeout dominance, Olson’s total bases machine, and Harper on a scorching May run are the highlights from today’s slate. Here is the summary.
- Kyle Harrison OVER 6.5 Strikeouts (check your book for current lines)
- Matt Olson OVER 1.5 Total Bases (check your book for current lines)
- Bryce Harper OVER 1.5 Hits (check your book for current lines)
Grab your spots early, shop for the best number, and enjoy the games tonight. These are the plays worth having on your card.
The smartest 5 minutes in betting
Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.