Skip to content
MLB

2025 MLB Postseason: Best Bets, Player Props, and Parlay for Tuesday, September 30

By Wade Reeser Updated September 30, 2025
2025 MLB Postseason Best Bets, Player Props, and Parlay

The MLB regular season grind is behind us, and all eyes are set on October playoff baseball! As the focus and intensity ramp up, the 2025 playoffs kick off with four high-stakes Wild Card matchups.

In the National League, the Padres visit the Cubs, as the Dodgers host the Reds. In the American League, the Tigers and Guardians continue their never-ending matchup, while the Red Sox and Yankees renew their October rivalry.

All four series bring intriguing pitching matchups, plenty of offensive power, and underdogs that could bite this postseason! Below is today’s schedule, along with our best bets to give you guys plenty of action to follow. Enjoy October baseball!

MLB Playoff Games for Tuesday, September 30

  • 1:00 PM Detroit (Skubal) @ Cleveland (Williams) (ESPN)
  • 3:00 PM San Diego (Pivetta) @ Chicago (Boyd) (ABC)
  • 6:00 PM Boston (Crochet) @ New York (Fried) (ESPN)
  • 9:00 PM Cincinnati (Greene) @ Los Angeles (Snell) (ESPN)

Best Bet: Padres ML (+106, ProphetX)

The Padres at plus money stand out as one of the stronger values on the board. Yes, I know we saw this matchup in April and Boyd outpitched Pivetta, but I like the Padres’ offense in this opening match. Their ability to stack quality at-bats from top to bottom makes them dangerous against a pitcher like Matthew Boyd, who has been steady but not dominant.

Boyd’s 1st half and 2nd half numbers are quite different. In the month of August, over 35 innings pitched, Boyd has a 4.54 ERA and 2.99 wOBA, allowing 31 hits and 18 runs. San Diego’s bullpen advantage also plays a huge role here; in a short series where every run matters, the late innings can tilt the outcome.

Per InsidethePen.com, the Padres rank as the current 2nd-best bullpen in effectiveness and best bullpen in 2025. They lead the MLB in saves and have the better bullpen ERA over the last 14 days and full season. If the Padres can get an early lead and force the Cubs to play catch-up, it may be difficult to put up a ton of runs with projected winds of 10 mph in and a total of 7.

San Diego comes in with an offense that can break open games in a hurry and has the recent playoff history to suggest they have the upper hand to do one better than last year. Their mix of star power and depth gives them one of the most versatile lineups in the postseason. The bullpen, once a liability, has developed into a strength and could be a deciding factor in a tight Wild Card showdown.

Best Bet: Red Sox ML (+125, Novig)

Boston isn’t just live tonight behind Crochet; they’re capable of outright winning this series if their rotation holds up and their offense can generate some runs minus injured Roman Anthony. Crochet gives them a legitimate ace to lean on, and Bregman brings championship experience and leadership to this offense.

Crochet’s presence neutralizes much of New York’s power and the Sox have dominated the Yankees all year winning 9 of their 13 matchups. Crochet faced this offense four times this season, the Red Sox winning all four. To add to Crochet’s success the Sox are also 14-6 in their last 20 road games, good for 70%.

I do expect this to be a pitchers’ duel even though we have seen Crochet give up runs in the past and in his two starts in Yankee stadium we saw high scoring affairs. Max Fried brings a Bonafide ace to the mound the Yankees can not only trust, but one who can get them deep into games.

The Yankees do bring the better bullpen into this matchup, but the Sox will lean on Crochet and if things are going well, I expect him to see six or seven innings to help keep the bullpen’s best arms as fresh as possible. If you look at the current form, sure the Yankees have won eight straight and eleven out of twelve, but no one is talking about that against Baltimore in two series, the White Sox, and the Twins, all four terrible teams. Meanwhile the Red Sox, playing meaningful baseball to end their season, had to face the Tigers and Blue Jays in their final two series, keeping them battle tested and the intensity cranked up in every game. +125 is too good to pass up.

Best Parlay: Dodgers ML + Blake Snell 6+ Strikeouts (−125, Fanatics)

The Dodgers enter October as one of the most complete rosters in baseball, winning 8 of their last 10 overall, 4 of their last 5 at home and 7 of their last 10 at home. Now a seasoned playoff team, they get a Reds team who squeaked into the playoffs, and I am not buying their offense. Perhaps +160 to +190 is too good to pass up on the Reds behind their ace Greene, but I have to back the veteran squad turning it on at the right time.

Adding Blake Snell’s strikeout prop brings down the ML price and while I don’t hate the +115 -1.5 line for Dodgers or the 6.5 K line for Snell, he hasn’t hit 6+ Ks in the playoffs since 2020, and this Reds roster has not been giving up a ton of Ks. Play the 6.5 line but don’t hammer it, if he is locked in and his curveball is working, he can find 12, but if his command is loose, he could struggle to get to 6.

Matthew Boyd Over 4.5 Hits Allowed (−112, Novig)

Boyd has been a solid starter this season, one we backed quite a bit in the middle stretch of the season. His current form and head-to-head history suggest he’s likely to give up traffic in this one. He allowed 5 and 6 hits in his prior two starts vs the Padres this season. He has also allowed this to cash in 6 of his last 7 overall starts and 3 of his last 4 at home.

Boyd generates a 17% whiff rate against this lineup, a lineup that has been at the bottom of the league over the last few years in strike out rate. He will pitch to contact and if they can find the gaps, this offense could put up 6-10 hits in a hurry. The Padres’ lineup is full of high IQ and aggressive hitters. Boyd’s allowed batting average goes to .277 the 2nd time through the order. The first 4 innings could be critical in this one.

Garrett Crochet Over 17.5 Outs (−115, Novig)

Crochet’s usage all season has pointed toward durability, and in the postseason, the Red Sox will need him to deliver on that. Even in games where he allowed 3+, a couple 6 and 7 ER, they still allowed him to go a full 6 innings. Now with a leaky bullpen, even if he gives up 3-4, they still may allow him to stay in if he can settle in.

Crochet cashed this line in 25 of 32 games, good for 72% overall, ending the season hitting this eight straight, 12 of 13, and 20 of his last 22. Head-to-head this season, Crochet has cashed all four games, going into the 7th inning in two of the four games.

Free · Weekly

The smartest 5 minutes in betting

Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.