Monday night at Madison Square Garden has the feel of a game that refuses to behave. The Montreal Canadiens (12-4-4) roll into New York to face a Rangers team (12-8-1) that has won five of its last six, and the books have this one sitting at a coin flip with a total of 6.5. When a game looks that even, the fun move is to skip the side and build a parlay around the players who can actually swing the night.
That is exactly what we are doing here: two goal scorers, a shot prop for the Rangers’ hottest forward, and the game total. Puck drop is 7:30 PM ET. Every price below is what was posted at the time of writing, so check your book before you lock anything in.
Leg 1: Cole Caufield Anytime Goal (+120)
Caufield is the most likely goal scorer on the board, and it is not hard to see why. He leads Montreal with 12 goals and 19 points in 20 games, has a point in six straight, and scored on four shots in Friday’s 5-2 win in Boston. He has fired 67 shots this season, which is north of three per night, and two of his goals have come on the power play.
FanDuel has him at +120, which implies roughly a 45 percent chance. That is not a long shot, but it is a fair price for a sniper who also scored twice against this same Rangers team in April. New York is also down its franchise goalie, with Igor Shesterkin on injured reserve for the season.
Leg 2: Nick Suzuki Anytime Goal (+160)
Suzuki is the playmaker, but do not sleep on his shot. He has eight goals and 17 points in 14 games, better than a point per game, and he has eight points in his last five meetings with the Rangers. At +160, the market is pricing him mostly as a passer, which undersells a center who is clearly scoring his share this season.
Stacking Caufield and Suzuki is the classic correlated play. If one scores at even strength, there is a good chance the other had a hand in it, and both skate on the top power-play unit with Juraj Slafkovsky and Lane Hutson. It is the kind of pairing that makes a parlay feel less like a lottery ticket and more like a script.
Leg 3: Mika Zibanejad Over 2.5 Shots on Goal (+132)
Every good parlay needs a Rangers voice, and Zibanejad is the one. He carries a five-game point streak into this matchup and has 19 points this season. FanDuel has the over at +132, plus money for a center who sees top-line and power-play minutes.
This is the riskiest leg, since some projections have him closer to 1.8 shots. The reward is a payout bump for the whole slip, and it gives you a stake in the New York side if the Rangers come out flying at home. An entertainment-forward slip should have at least one swing like this.
Leg 4: Over 6.5 Total Goals (+113)
The total is where this gets interesting. The Canadiens average 3.30 goals per game on the road, and Montreal’s 13.3 percent power play has been the only thing holding the offense back. The counter-argument is real: the Rangers have a strong penalty kill at 89.1 percent, and some models lean under 6.5.
But if you are already betting two goal scorers and a shot prop, the over is the natural partner. The game does not need to be a fireworks show; it needs one sloppy period. Over 6.5 is posted around +113 to +114 at several books, and a first-period over 1.5 is a way to shrink the risk to 20 minutes if you prefer.
The Full Parlay
The slip: Cole Caufield anytime goal, Nick Suzuki anytime goal, Mika Zibanejad over 2.5 shots on goal, and over 6.5 total goals. Because these legs are correlated, most sportsbooks price the combo lower than a straight multiplication of the odds, so confirm the final payout in your bet slip. If you are new to this format, our same game parlays guide explains how it works, and you can compare NHL odds before picking a book.
Is it a lock? No parlay ever is. But if Caufield keeps his streak alive, Suzuki joins the party, and the Rangers and Canadiens turn the Garden into a track meet, this one pays well and gives you something to cheer about all night. Bet only what you can afford to lose, and use the player prop search to shop for the best number on each leg.
The smartest 5 minutes in betting
Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.