Best MLB Props to Bet Today, May 20: Schlittler, Sale, and Hancock Have Us Covered

Wednesday has 15 MLB games on the schedule and we’re not sitting this one out. After digging through the pitching matchups, the batter splits, and the odds board, three props jumped off the page as genuine edges worth betting. We’ve got a dominant young starter, a living legend in vintage form, and a sneaky good arm nobody’s talking about.

Grab your favorite beverage, settle in, and let’s make some money on May 20.

Cam Schlittler: The Best Pitcher You Haven’t Bet Enough This Year

If you haven’t been backing Cam Schlittler every single week this season, you’ve been leaving money on the table. The Yankees’ rookie right-hander wearing number 31 is posting a 1.35 ERA with 68 strikeouts in just 60.0 innings across 10 starts. He’s 6-1 on the season, opponents are hitting a laughable .168 against him, and he leads the entire American League in ERA and WHIP. This isn’t a hot streak — it’s a historic rookie campaign.

Today he faces the Blue Jays, and the line on his strikeout total is sitting right where the books have been underestimating him all year. In his last five starts, Schlittler has posted 8, 6, 5, 8, and 6 strikeouts. He’s cleared 5.5 in six of his ten outings. Toronto isn’t particularly great at putting the ball in play against high-velocity starters. Back Schlittler’s strikeout over tonight — check your book for current lines — and enjoy watching him paint.

Chris Sale vs. the Marlins Is an Absolute Gift

Chris Sale is 37 years old and somehow pitching the best baseball of his life. The Braves’ ace, number 51, has a 1.96 ERA through nine starts and 64 strikeouts in 55 innings. His last four starts produced 8, 7, 11, and 8 Ks — that’s 34 strikeouts over a four-start stretch. For perspective, his lowest strikeout output in any of his last seven starts was six.

Tonight Sale draws the Marlins at loanDepot park. Miami is 22-27, their offense has been inconsistent all season, and they’re facing a pitcher who is on one of the most dominant runs of any starter in baseball right now. The Marlins ranked near the bottom of the NL in plate discipline metrics through the first half of May. Sale’s breaking ball is historically nasty and the environment tonight sets up for another big strikeout night. Jump on Sale’s strikeout over and thank yourself later — check your book for current lines.

Emerson Hancock Is Quietly Putting Together a Breakout Season

Emerson Hancock doesn’t get the headlines of some of the other starters on today’s slate, but the Mariners right-hander wearing number — well, look him up — has transformed this season. Through eight starts he’s at a 3.02 ERA with 56 strikeouts across 47.2 innings, and his last outing against San Diego was six clean innings with six strikeouts. His most dramatic performance of the season was a seven-inning, 14-strikeout masterpiece against Kansas City on May 2.

Tonight he faces the Chicago White Sox at T-Mobile Park, which plays as a pitcher-friendly environment. The White Sox carry a 25-23 record but have been susceptible to missing breaking balls from right-handed starters. Hancock’s strikeout rate of 9.44 per nine innings in 2026 is dramatically better than his career average, suggesting real development in his pitch mix. His 5.5 strikeout line tonight looks like a strong over — check your book for current lines and get in before first pitch.

Wednesday’s MVP Props Board

Three pitchers. Three genuine edges. Whether you’re building a parlay or playing them straight, this is a board worth action on a full Wednesday slate.

• Cam Schlittler OVER 5.5 strikeouts (check your book for current lines)
• Chris Sale OVER 6.5 strikeouts (check your book for current lines)
• Emerson Hancock OVER 5.5 strikeouts (check your book for current lines)

Wednesday night baseball with props is genuinely one of life’s small pleasures. Lock these in, check back on the live lines as game time approaches, and enjoy the action.