Skip to content
NBA

Knicks vs Pacers Betting Guide: 2 Player Props and Best Bet for Game 4

By Jaden Vann Updated May 27, 2025
Knicks vs Pacers 2 Player Props and Best Bet for Game 4

The New York Knicks can push their away playoff record to 7-1 tonight as they take on an Indiana Pacers team that held a 20-point lead in the second quarter of Game 3. Now, with the series 2-1 in favor of Indiana, Brunson and Towns will look to stay out of foul trouble to push this series back to MSG, all tied up.

One player to keep an eye out for is the incredible Mikal Bridges, who should finally get hot from beyond the arc in Game 4. Check out our entire betting card below. Good luck, folks!

Wednesday, October 21 at 8:10 PMSpreadMoneyTotal
Indiana Pacers
-4.5
(-105)
-165
O 243.5
(-110)
New Orleans Pelicans
+4.5
(-115)
+140
U 242.5
(-110)

Best Bet: New York Knicks +2

The Knicks found something in their clutch Game 3 victory over Indiana after being down by 20 points in the second quarter of play. With Brunson and Towns in foul trouble all of the second half, the rest of the Knicks stepped up.

Anunoby was elite defensively, while the unsung hero Miles Deuce McBride showed up offensively when it mattered the most. This momentum should carry into Tuesday’s Game 4, with New York playing their best playoff basketball on the road, sporting a 6-1 record in road games this postseason.

Last year, it was New York that squandered a 2-0 series lead, letting Indiana win two games at home to swing the series momentum. This trend gets repeated tonight as the Knicks will take this series back to The Garden all square.

Mikal Bridges (NYK) OVER 1.5 3PM

Bridges is quite possibly the most underrated 3rd or 4th option in the league. He is built for the postseason and moments like this, with the ability to play at all three levels on offense and guard 1-5 on defense.

Mikal has made just 2/10 threes this series and throughout this postseason has shot the ball just 31% from beyond the arc. Playing 40 minutes in this Game 4 with New York looking to play at their own pace and confusing the Pacers’ defense on constant switches, I believe Mikal will finally heat up tonight from beyond the arc and get a few open looks early in this game with the focus on Brunson and Towns.

Bridges hasn’t had three straight playoff games with fewer than two made threes since the Suns’ 2022 series against Dallas that knocked them out of the postseason.

Andrew Nembhard (IND) UNDER 8.5 Rebounds & Assists

While I am the biggest Andrew Nembhard believer and fan, his 8.5 RA prop is a tall task to hit, especially with the way this series has gone for the undersized clutch guard. Nembhard has been a solid scorer, going 15/12/9 points on efficient shooting numbers for Indiana thus far.

However, with Mitchell Robinson, KAT, and Hart on one side and Siakam, Turner, Haliburton, and Toppin on Indiana’s side, rebounding numbers have fallen for Nembhard, who hasn’t hit this prop in a single game this series.

Although the usage and minutes will be there for the young guard, he is more of a mid-range scorer and transition facilitator this series, instead of a pure playmaking scorer. T.J. McConnell has also cut into Andrew’s stats, averaging an absurd 10.7 PPG and 6.0 RA per game in just 14.7 minutes of playing time in these three matchups against New York.

Free · Weekly

The smartest 5 minutes in betting

Get the week's best offers, line moves, and data-driven picks — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Join 240,000+ subscribers. 21+ only.